This index lists over four thousand known and possible New Netherland residents, and is used in the development of New Netherland Settler Sketches. This list will be continuously curated and added to, working with an objective of inclusion and the broadest definition of New Netherland as possible.
| Name (sorted A to Z; select to sort Z to A) | Origin (select to sort) | Arrival (select to sort) | Settled (select to sort) | Spouses (select to sort) | Sketch (select to sort) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pigeon, William | English | 1657 | Flushing | ||
| Pimadaase | Native American | ||||
| Pinckney, Philip | English | 1664 | Eastchester | Jane | |
| Piscamoc | Native American | ||||
| Plank, Jacob | Dutch | 1634 | Rensselaerswyck | ||
| Platneus, Jan | Danish | 1647 | New Amsterdam | Neeltje Douwes | |
| Plettenburg, Grietje | Jan Doreth; Willem van der Schuuren | ||||
| Pleuntie | Frederick Gysbertszen | ||||
| Plockhoy, Pieter Corneliszen | Dutch | 1663 | Mennonite Settlement South (Delaware) River Germantown PA | ||
| Plodder, Jacob | Dutch | 1637 | Rensselaerswyck Beverwyck; Kinderhook | Josyna; Barentje Stratsman | |
| Pluvier, Cornelis | Dutch | 1662 | New Amsterdam | Geertruyde Andries; Neeltje | |
| Pokahake | Native American | ||||
| Polhemius, Johannes Theodorus | German | 1654 | Flatbush | Unknown; Unknown | |
| Ponitaranachgyne | Native American | ||||
| Pontianes, Jacob | Dutch | 1661 | New Amsterdam | Neeltje Huygen; Annetje Minnen | |
| Ponton, Richard | English | 1655 | Town of Westchester | Unknown | |
| Pootman, Jan | Dutch | 1661 | Rensselaerswyck; Beverwyck | Cornelia | |
| Popinga, Thomas | Dutch | 1662 | New Amsterdam | Marritje | |
| Porter, George | English | 1664 | Esopus; Marbletown | ||
| Portugies, Anthonij | African |