How to use periodicals for New York Dutch genealogy research
Millions of Americans have colonial Dutch ancestry, and many who spend time researching their New York Dutch ancestors face research problems related to this important group of settlers.
The colonial Dutch can be a tricky group to research - not only are records about them some of the oldest in America, but there are cultural practices - for instance, Dutch naming patterns - that can often complicate research.
Fortunately, there is a large body of existing, thoroughly vetted research on many New York Dutch families, and there are many ways in which a researcher can leverage this work to make further discoveries.
Whether you’re seeking an early immigrant’s country of origin, looking to prove your definitive link back to a colonial Dutch family, or just interested in exploring more about the earliest families of New York, it’s well worth exploring existing research on New York’s colonial Dutch families.
As with many areas of family history research, one of the very first steps in approaching a New York Dutch research problem should be to determine what has already been compiled on the family in question and other associated families.
Genealogy periodicals are the perfect place to look - in this article, we’ll review how researchers may use the archives of The Record and other periodicals to examine the hundreds of compiled genealogies, pedigrees, and case studies on New York’s colonial Dutch families.
If you’re an NYG&B member, we recommend Henry B. Hoff’s article in the New York Knowledge Base, Researching New York Dutch Families: A Checklist Approach - a few of his suggestions are mentioned here, but he covers more options for Dutch research and lists dozens of additional sources and references to explore.
And if you’re interested in Dutch history, you may be interested in our Fall Benefit Luncheon on October 26 - award-winning author of Island at the Center of the World, Russell Shorto, will be the featured guest.
Why it's important to review already-existing work
Isaac Newton once famously remarked, “If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants.”
This is a worthy concept for genealogists to take to heart. There is certainly no need to repeat work that has already been done, but even more to the point, we should all be using the work of past genealogists to set us on the path to further discovery.
We may find articles that have been written specifically on the families or individuals of interest, but consulting the work in The Record will also provide excellent commentary not found elsewhere, as well as solutions to typical genealogical problems found in New York Dutch research.
These articles often provide:
- Analysis of typical genealogical problems found in Dutch research (see the examples below).
- Essential information on mainstream and under-utilized sources for New York Dutch research.
- Commentary and guidance on essential subjects related to the Colonial Dutch of New York, such as Dutch naming practices and the use, assessment, and analysis of crucial primary sources.
The articles may also contain accounts of associated families that may not be mentioned in the title of the article, or in subject indexes (more on these below).
Having been published continuously since 1870, The New York Genealogical and Biographical Society Record contains hundreds of articles on the colonial Dutch of New York, holding a treasure trove of information just waiting to be discovered.
Using The Record to assist your Dutch research
NYG&B members get access to the full digital archive of The Record as a benefit of society membership. A full-text search of The Record collection in the eLibrary will query every page of every issue that has been published - researchers can search by name, location, or keywords.
As Henry B. Hoff suggests in Researching New York Dutch Families: A Checklist Approach, it’s important for researchers to take the time to conduct a very careful and thorough reading of these articles in order to maximize the value gained.
Researchers who are not NYG&B members may use the indexes to The Record, which are free and open to the public, to review article subjects and the names found within them.
Worden’s Every Name index to The Record is a searchable database that contains every name that appears in an article in The Record - it will give the volume and page number that name appears on. With that information, it's easy to use citations and index entries for The Record to find the full article.
Worden's and Macy’s Subject indexes to The Record can be used to explore Dutch research in a few ways - names that appear in these indexes indicate that the named family is heavily featured in the article. Additionally, researchers can look under terms such as “Dutch” or “New Netherland” to find additional articles that will be useful to their research.
Examples from The Record
Because of its depth and volume, it would be impossible to list all articles that may be useful for researchers in The Record.
Here are just a few examples that Henry B. Hoff mentions and why they are important for researchers focusing on New York Dutch to read:
"Gerrit Hendricks De Wees: 17th Century Dutch Immigrant to New Amsterdam"
This article, written by Curtis Dewees and Jack C. Vaughn in volume 125 of The Record, summarizes research that corrected past misconceptions about this immigrant Dutch family. The article is a prime example for researchers because part of it tackles a familiar problem of identity - do records of a Gerrit Hendricks from Amsterdam all refer to the same man? In addition, it addresses Dutch naming practices, which were the cause of earlier mistakes, which the authors suggest "had arisen in large part due to lack of familiarity with the continued use of the patronymic system of naming in America."
"A Johnson/Jansen Family of Brooklyn and New York"
This article, written for volume 111 of The Record by Henry B. Hoff, examines a "three brothers" legend related to the purported origin of the General Jeremiah Johnson family of Brooklyn. Aside from being an interesting read about the origins of a well-known New York family, researchers should examine in detail how the author uses an analysis of the place of birth and residence given in marriage records to show relationship.
"The Verschuer Family of Bushwick: Its Roots in the Netherlands and Descendants Through Comegys, Fyn, Duryea, Covert, and Simonson"
This installment of an article written by Harry Macy Jr., also in volume 125 of The Record, focuses on identifying Magdalena Verschuer as the wife of Joost Duryea Jr. An entire installment in a series of articles about these families is dedicated to this problem and solution since it's an interesting and noteworthy case study. The author cracks the problem by analyzing naming patterns and the husband's contacts as a witness among other methods.
"Gerritsen-Garrison, Van Wicklen, Hardenbergh, Wiltsie: Descendants of Gerrit Lubbersten of Jamaica, L.I."
Harry Macy Jr. also authored this article, found in volume 116 of The Record. The article tackles a mystery involving an early eighteenth-century group of people in Jamaica Queens, bearing the patronymic Gerrits(en), but no other surname. Although, as he notes, "records for the time and place are typically incomplete" (a challenge facing many New York Dutch researchers), he was able to provide sufficient evidence that all of these Gerritsens in Jamaica "were brothers and sisters, the hitherto largely unidentified children of Gerrit Lubbertsen and his wife Geertruy Willems Van Boerum." The author solves this problem through analyzing baptismal sponsors found in records, but also interpreting evidence in light of typical Dutch naming patterns.
Don't overlook other periodicals: Use PERSI
Henry B. Hoff mentions several additional resources for locating these crucial periodical articles in Researching New York Dutch Families: A Checklist Approach - we highly recommend NYG&B members interested in this subject read his full article.
One that he mentions is the Periodical Source Index, widely referred to as PERSI.
PERSI is one of the most powerful, but under-utilized resources for genealogy research around today.
For many years, the Allen County Public Library in Allen County, Indiana, has been collecting genealogy and local history periodicals from around the world and building a comprehensive index to them. These periodicals will often have compiled genealogies and other research that is published and well-vetted.
There are so many articles in PERSI it’s almost guaranteed there is something in there that’s relevant to your research - there’s a lot in there about the New York Dutch, but many, many other subjects as well. Once an article of interest is found in the index, it is easy to get a copy.
This is important work and crucial for researchers because many articles in these periodicals are not easy to find in Google or other mainstream search engines - you’ll often find many things in PERSI that you have never seen before.
The best part is, PERSI is completely free to use - you can view the detailed index entries by creating a free account on findmypast.com, where PERSI is now hosted. Visit www.findmypast.com/persi to learn all about using this resource.
We hope this article has given you plenty of ideas and resources to help you build off of the amazing body of existing work New York Dutch families - if you have any favorite articles that you think are particularly useful for researchers to read, send us an email (along with your reasoning) to let us know and we'll add them to this post.
More Genealogy Reading
About the New York Genealogical and Biographical Society
Since 1869, our mission has been to help our thousands of worldwide members discover their family's New York story, and there has never been a better time to join.
The cost of an Individual Annual Membership is less than six dollars a month, and includes the following benefits:
- Access to over 50 exclusive digital record sets covering the entire state of New York, including the fully searchable archives of The Record.
- A complimentary subscription to all of Findmypast's North American records, as well as U.K. and Irish Census records.
- Access to hundreds of expert-authored Knowledge Base articles and webinars to help you navigate the tricky New York research landscape.
- Exclusive discounts and advanced access to conferences, seminars, workshops and lectures to learn more about researching people and places across New York State.
To learn more or join us, please visit our member benefits page.